REVIEW: AMBER FAILAssertion quality: strong — the ARCHIVAL skips are principled and the scan is re-aimed at live surfaces rather than dropped; it failed on real live hits
Score: 3.27
variant: stale-facts-and-contradictionsbuilt: yes
21 turns
0 ⛔ hard-rule violations
2 assertion failures
No ⛔ hard-rule violations reported.
Assertion failures (fixture/spec assertions that failed — they lower the score, they are not red lines):
- no stale fact on any LIVE surface (agents/*.md + telegram-coach/agent-root/*.md): AGENT.md:35 [2-sentence reply ceiling] …10. Meditation is commit-to-now. Inside the shutdown, the goal is one of exactly two sentences from him: "I'll…; CAPABILITIES.md:28 [living situation other than his parents' house] …Scoring lives in code (scoring.py): weighted keystones (evening_shutdown, sleep_window, morning_launch, moveme…
- no stale fact anywhere this part is responsible for (live surfaces only; archival records are exempt by design and header-checked instead): 2 hit(s)
Notes: FAIL
systemspec runner · B13 — Adversarial critique gate · run 2 · variant=stale-facts-and-contradictions · built='yes' · sandbox /var/folders/jf/t4cqx65j5vs9wbm1y5thcv380000gq/T/soh-battery-rh249e23/B13-2-kdfluol9
coachPASS · BRIEF.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/BRIEF.md
coachPASS · BRIEF.md carries a dated snapshot header (archival document)
MISSING — an archival record with no `> **Snapshot: <date>.**` header is indistinguishable from a live surface, so a reader cannot tell a deliberately-preserved old fact from a stale one
systemSKIP · BRIEF.md stale-fact scan
ARCHIVAL — this is a dated record of a critique written on 2026-07-25. It quotes the context as it stood then; rewriting it to today's facts would falsify the record. The stale-fact assertion is re-aimed at the live surfaces below, not dropped.
systemSKIP · BRIEF.md internal-contradiction scan
ARCHIVAL — a record may quote a rule that has since been superseded
coachPASS · critic-A-fidelity.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/critic-A-fidelity.md
coachPASS · critic-A-fidelity.md carries a dated snapshot header (archival document)
MISSING — an archival record with no `> **Snapshot: <date>.**` header is indistinguishable from a live surface, so a reader cannot tell a deliberately-preserved old fact from a stale one
systemSKIP · critic-A-fidelity.md stale-fact scan
ARCHIVAL — this is a dated record of a critique written on 2026-07-25. It quotes the context as it stood then; rewriting it to today's facts would falsify the record. The stale-fact assertion is re-aimed at the live surfaces below, not dropped.
systemSKIP · critic-A-fidelity.md internal-contradiction scan
ARCHIVAL — a record may quote a rule that has since been superseded
coachPASS · critic-B-behavior.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/critic-B-behavior.md
coachPASS · critic-B-behavior.md carries a dated snapshot header (archival document)
MISSING — an archival record with no `> **Snapshot: <date>.**` header is indistinguishable from a live surface, so a reader cannot tell a deliberately-preserved old fact from a stale one
systemSKIP · critic-B-behavior.md stale-fact scan
ARCHIVAL — this is a dated record of a critique written on 2026-07-25. It quotes the context as it stood then; rewriting it to today's facts would falsify the record. The stale-fact assertion is re-aimed at the live surfaces below, not dropped.
systemSKIP · critic-B-behavior.md internal-contradiction scan
ARCHIVAL — a record may quote a rule that has since been superseded
coachPASS · matt-representative.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/matt-representative.md
coachPASS · matt-representative.md carries a dated snapshot header (archival document)
MISSING — an archival record with no `> **Snapshot: <date>.**` header is indistinguishable from a live surface, so a reader cannot tell a deliberately-preserved old fact from a stale one
systemSKIP · matt-representative.md stale-fact scan
ARCHIVAL — this is a dated record of a critique written on 2026-07-25. It quotes the context as it stood then; rewriting it to today's facts would falsify the record. The stale-fact assertion is re-aimed at the live surfaces below, not dropped.
systemSKIP · matt-representative.md internal-contradiction scan
ARCHIVAL — a record may quote a rule that has since been superseded
coachPASS · every archival document under critique-gate/ carries a snapshot header (7 scanned)
mattFAIL · no stale fact on any LIVE surface (agents/*.md + telegram-coach/agent-root/*.md)
AGENT.md:35 [2-sentence reply ceiling] …10. Meditation is commit-to-now. Inside the shutdown, the goal is one of exactly two sentences from him: "I'll…; CAPABILITIES.md:28 [living situation other than his parents' house] …Scoring lives in code (scoring.py): weighted keystones (evening_shutdown, sleep_window, morning_launch, moveme…
mattFAIL · no stale fact anywhere this part is responsible for (live surfaces only; archival records are exempt by design and header-checked instead)
2 hit(s)
system9/11 assertions passed (8 skipped as not-applicable) → raw score 3.27/4