REVIEW: GREEN PASSAssertion quality: strong — 16 rows across four real critic documents, each anchored to a named contract (VERDICT/FINDINGS shape, persona separation)
Score: 4.0
variant: required-sectionsbuilt: yes
18 turns
0 ⛔ hard-rule violations
0 assertion failures
No ⛔ hard-rule violations reported.
No assertion failures.
Notes: PASS
systemspec runner · B13 — Adversarial critique gate · run 1 · variant=required-sections · built='yes' · sandbox /var/folders/jf/t4cqx65j5vs9wbm1y5thcv380000gq/T/soh-battery-rh249e23/B13-1-5x97eanl
coachPASS · BRIEF.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/BRIEF.md
coachPASS · BRIEF.md is substantive
3636 bytes
coachPASS · BRIEF.md defines section: what is critiqued
^##\s*What is being critiqued
coachPASS · BRIEF.md defines section: ground truth
^##\s*Ground truth
coachPASS · critic-A-fidelity.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/critic-A-fidelity.md
coachPASS · critic-A-fidelity.md is substantive
30387 bytes
coachPASS · critic-A-fidelity.md defines section: VERDICT
^##\s*VERDICT
coachPASS · critic-A-fidelity.md defines section: FINDINGS
^##\s*FINDINGS
coachPASS · critic-B-behavior.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/critic-B-behavior.md
coachPASS · critic-B-behavior.md is substantive
33009 bytes
coachPASS · critic-B-behavior.md defines section: VERDICT
^##\s*VERDICT
coachPASS · critic-B-behavior.md defines section: FINDINGS
^##\s*FINDINGS
coachPASS · matt-representative.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/matt-representative.md
coachPASS · matt-representative.md is substantive
32866 bytes
coachPASS · matt-representative.md defines section: the collisions
^##\s*The collisions
coachPASS · matt-representative.md defines section: keep as is
^##\s*Keep exactly as is
system16/16 assertions passed (0 skipped as not-applicable) → raw score 4.0/4