REVIEW: AMBER PARTIALAssertion quality: strong — imports the production modal_app.py, calls mark.local() for real, and reads the persisted state.json; the reporting is what lets it down
Score: — no behavioural scorePARTIAL — PARTS.md built = 'partial (marker scaffolding)' — a behavioural score would overstate what actually runs (spec-conformance only: 4.0/4 — not comparable to a built part, never averaged)
variant: marker-roundtripbuilt: partial (marker scaffolding)
17 turns
0 ⛔ hard-rule violations
0 assertion failures
No ⛔ hard-rule violations reported.
No assertion failures.
Notes: PASS
systemfixture runner · B6 — Escalation ladder · run 1 · variant=marker-roundtrip · built='partial (marker scaffolding)' · sandbox /var/folders/jf/t4cqx65j5vs9wbm1y5thcv380000gq/T/soh-battery-nx3iu__q/B6-1-v4oo5q33
coachPASS · ESCALATION.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/.claude/skills/I-will-do-a-planning-session-in-15-mins/ESCALATION.md
coachPASS · ESCALATION.md specifies all 7 ladder states
missing []
coachPASS · ESCALATION.md carries an honest spec-vs-shipped diff
coachPASS · modal_app.py present
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/telegram-coach/scripts/modal_app.py
coachPASS · SKILL.md STEP 0 curls the mark endpoint with key planning_invoked:<ISO date>
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/.claude/skills/I-will-do-a-planning-session-in-15-mins/SKILL.md
coachPASS · modal_app.py is key-agnostic (the literal appears only in comments/docstrings)
the marker key is supplied by the caller; asserting the literal in source would pass on a comment
coachPASS · production modal_app.py imports in-process
coachPASS · sandbox gate: modal_app resolved COACH_DATA_DIR to the temp sandbox
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/telegram-coach/.tmp/skill-sims/data
coachPASS · mark() rejects a bad token
{'ok': False, 'error': 'bad token'}
coachPASS · mark() accepts the real token and echoes the key
{'ok': True, 'key': 'planning_invoked:2099-01-02'}
coachPASS · the marker is PERSISTED to state.json by the real write path
markers=['planning_invoked:2099-01-02']
coachPASS · the key the coach actually wrote is planning_invoked:<ISO date>
written key = 'planning_invoked:2099-01-02'
coachPASS · the marker carries a numeric timestamp (day-scoped breadcrumb)
coachPASS · _fire_outbox gates queued rungs on cancel_if_marker vs state markers (live code)
not found in the live body of _fire_outbox
coachPASS · a marker-cancelled rung is recorded as 'cancelled', not silently dropped
system15/15 assertions passed (0 skipped as not-applicable) → raw score 4.0/4