REVIEW: AMBER PARTIALAssertion quality: strong in what it targets (the gate itself: no --tab must still hit CoachTest) — but the reporting contradicts the result
Score: — no behavioural scorePARTIAL — PARTS.md built = 'script yes — never run live' — a behavioural score would overstate what actually runs (spec-conformance only: 4.0/4 — not comparable to a built part, never averaged)
variant: sandbox-tab-honouredbuilt: script yes — never run live
7 turns
0 ⛔ hard-rule violations
0 assertion failures
No ⛔ hard-rule violations reported.
No assertion failures.
Notes: PASS
systemfixture runner · B5 — "60-Day Challenge" sheet tab · run 2 · variant=sandbox-tab-honoured · built='script yes — never run live' · sandbox /var/folders/jf/t4cqx65j5vs9wbm1y5thcv380000gq/T/soh-battery-nx3iu__q/B5-2-9me9qp6v
coachPASS · make_sheet_tab.py exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/scripts/make_sheet_tab.py
coachPASS · sandbox gate: COACH_SHEET_TAB is CoachTest
coachPASS · make_sheet_tab.py reads COACH_SHEET_TAB in live code
NOT READ — the project-wide sandbox tab var is ignored by this script
coachPASS · with no --tab, the LIVE '60-Day Challenge' tab is still never targeted
exit 0; output named the live tab: [dry-run] would ensure tab 'CoachTest' with 14 columns + 61 day rows (Day 0 = 2026-07-25, today = Day 1)
[dry-run] header: Day# | Date | R1 plan ✓ | R2 morning audio ✓ | R3 15-min exercise ✓ | R4 plan
coachPASS · with no --tab, the sandbox tab is what gets targeted
[dry-run] would ensure tab 'CoachTest' with 14 columns + 61 day rows (Day 0 = 2026-07-25, today = Day 1)
[dry-run] header: Day# | Date | R1 plan ✓ | R2 morning audio ✓ | R3 15-min exercise ✓ | R4 plan
system5/5 assertions passed (0 skipped as not-applicable) → raw score 4.0/4