REVIEW: AMBER FAILAssertion quality: weak — 21 rows that reduce to existence/size/header checks on four files, plus three stale-fact false positives; nothing asserts the gate grades or blocks anything
Score: 2.67
variant: stale-facts-and-contradictionsbuilt: yes
15 turns
3 ⛔ hard-rule violations
0 assertion failures
⛔ Hard-rule violations (judge-issued conduct red lines — the SOH-22 gate):
- critic-B-behavior.md carries no stale fact (4 rule(s) applicable: 2-sentence reply ceiling, Gergo/Kocsy treated as two people, Gergo/Kocsy given an official role, living situation other than his parents' house): critic-B-behavior.md:418 [living situation other than his parents' house] …**Against.** `matt-core-context.md` L27: he moved to Lisbon for *"sun, nightlife, a young…
- matt-representative.md carries no stale fact (2 rule(s) applicable: 2-sentence reply ceiling, living situation other than his parents' house): matt-representative.md:267 [2-sentence reply ceiling] …replies short — 2 sentences max"* and *"Keep replies shorter and stop asking about cola"*…; matt-representative.md:391 [living situation other than his parents' house] …planning got blurry — started by hand, then moved to AI voice agent which is still in test phase…; matt-representative.md:438 [2-sentence reply ceiling] …each chat"* [`cgptvoice-095`]. Two sentences. Then the number.…
- no stale fact anywhere in this part's spec: 4 hit(s)
No assertion failures.
Notes: FAIL
systemspec runner · B13 — Adversarial critique gate · run 2 · variant=stale-facts-and-contradictions · built='yes' · sandbox /var/folders/jf/t4cqx65j5vs9wbm1y5thcv380000gq/T/soh-battery-5u_6qkk2/B13-2-jt06uv0n
coachPASS · BRIEF.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/BRIEF.md
coachPASS · BRIEF.md carries no stale fact (1 rule(s) applicable: living situation other than his parents' house)
systemSKIP · BRIEF.md internal-contradiction scan
NOT APPLICABLE — the document neither asserts nor rejects the reply-length ceiling, so the contradiction pattern has nothing to match
coachPASS · critic-A-fidelity.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/critic-A-fidelity.md
coachPASS · critic-A-fidelity.md carries no stale fact (2 rule(s) applicable: 2-sentence reply ceiling, living situation other than his parents' house)
systemSKIP · critic-A-fidelity.md internal-contradiction scan
NOT APPLICABLE — the document neither asserts nor rejects the reply-length ceiling, so the contradiction pattern has nothing to match
coachPASS · critic-B-behavior.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/critic-B-behavior.md
mattFAIL · critic-B-behavior.md carries no stale fact (4 rule(s) applicable: 2-sentence reply ceiling, Gergo/Kocsy treated as two people, Gergo/Kocsy given an official role, living situation other than his parents' house)
critic-B-behavior.md:418 [living situation other than his parents' house] …**Against.** `matt-core-context.md` L27: he moved to Lisbon for *"sun, nightlife, a young…
systemSKIP · critic-B-behavior.md internal-contradiction scan
NOT APPLICABLE — the document neither asserts nor rejects the reply-length ceiling, so the contradiction pattern has nothing to match
coachPASS · matt-representative.md exists
/Users/agency/Documents/Agty/telegram coach/plans/system-reset-2026-07-25/critique-gate/matt-representative.md
mattFAIL · matt-representative.md carries no stale fact (2 rule(s) applicable: 2-sentence reply ceiling, living situation other than his parents' house)
matt-representative.md:267 [2-sentence reply ceiling] …replies short — 2 sentences max"* and *"Keep replies shorter and stop asking about cola"*…; matt-representative.md:391 [living situation other than his parents' house] …planning got blurry — started by hand, then moved to AI voice agent which is still in test phase…; matt-representative.md:438 [2-sentence reply ceiling] …each chat"* [`cgptvoice-095`]. Two sentences. Then the number.…
systemSKIP · matt-representative.md internal-contradiction scan
NOT APPLICABLE — the document neither asserts nor rejects the reply-length ceiling, so the contradiction pattern has nothing to match
mattFAIL · no stale fact anywhere in this part's spec
4 hit(s)
system6/9 assertions passed (4 skipped as not-applicable) → raw score 2.67/4