# Acceptance ledger — orchestrator reconciliation of REV-01..REV-15

Every row was reconciled by the orchestrator against the artifact itself, not against the lane's
claim about the artifact. Where a lane's claim did not survive that check, the row records the
correction and cites the check that produced it.

**Goal:** `goal-v1.md`, SHA-256 `287532968913b5b5fda888cdf38f02496a523ed2314f4da91e4d4ba3b49690e8`
**Verdict:** 15 of 15 PASS.

| Row | Verdict | Evidence and the check that produced it |
| --- | --- | --- |
| REV-01 | **PASS** | `source-and-state-register.md`. Baseline `round-13-takeover` at `8351b59`. Build-run status established per task, then **corrected twice** by independent orchestrator checks: (a) `git merge-base --is-ancestor 638e7524 round-13-takeover` → false, so the handoff's own named fixed point is not on the reviewed branch and 41 files were absent from every child worktree (ORCH-CORR-1); (b) `git -C /home/matt/mirror/Fusion-ppc-children/t2 status --porcelain -uall` → 2 modified, 5 untracked, 313 lines, so "T2 produced nothing" was true of git and false of disk. Both corrections are recorded in the register rather than silently applied. Reproduction commands included. |
| REV-02 | **PASS** | `requirements-traceability.md`, 51 rows. Matt's requirements carry verbatim quotes with session ID and turn number (`019ff730-b932-73c2-9f77-f5ccd4c498b7` T0001/T0008, `01a03268-01b7-7700-a436-1bba5b154b24` T0001, `01a04df6-2370-7071-a178-42aa9e3cad05` T0006, `01a04a52-f05d-7413-9806-7f7153209243` T0001/T0007). Counts: of 16 substantive requirements, **0 fully delivered**, 7 partly covered by pre-existing artifacts, 9 with no artifact; 3 constraint requirements honoured. **Limitation recorded, not hidden:** quotes were taken from the handoff and `GROUND-TRUTH.md`, not re-derived from the raw transcripts, which are Mac-local and unavailable on this host. |
| REV-03 | **PASS** | `user-flow-matrix.md`, all 16 mandated flows present as `## Flow 1` … `## Flow 16`, 66 step rows, each with expected / actual / evidence / state-handling / necessity / severity / smallest-fix / decisive-retest columns. Orchestrator spot-verified the highest-severity row (2.2, cache poisoning) against its cited source `deliverables/fusion-ppc-2026-07-30/evidence/tracking-audit.md` — the source states it directly and grades it P0 itself. |
| REV-04 | **PASS** | `browser-test-ledger.md`, 10 targets A–H exercised at 1280×900 DSF1 via Playwright, 71 graded interactions (38 pass / 33 fail), 36 screenshots and 17 JSON receipts under `evidence/lane2/`. Chrome on `:1`/`:9222` untouched. |
| REV-05 | **PASS** | Empty, partial, error, retry, stale and success states each assessed and each produced findings: **error→false-success** (F-22, the sort-header click that replaces "failed to load" with "no creatives match", reproduced twice byte-identical and confirmed by the orchestrator at `index.html:460` and `:519`); **stale** (F-21, cache HIT serving a prior visitor's click ID); **empty-versus-never-wired** (F-28, four CRM worksheets at 0/0); **partial** (F-13, `comparable: true` at 11 delivery days of 30); **success** (F-24, 20 of 20 thumbnails broken, decision column off-screen); **retry/recovery** (F-10, no watcher consumes the heartbeats the children write). |
| REV-06 | **PASS** | `measurement-and-trigger-ledger.md`, 38 measurement rows on the SPECIFIED / IMPLEMENTED / VERIFIED split with grain and join-key compatibility per row. Reconciliations: 49 platform conversions vs 13 register enquiries; five misaligned source windows enumerated; `conversion_value` carrying the count under `unit: "huf"` traced to `roas` = 0.000532056. Orchestrator independently re-read `report_data.json` for every headline figure quoted in this review. |
| REV-07 | **PASS** | Same file, 7 trigger rows. Logic, idempotency, visibility and recovery assessed per row. Root cause established with timestamps: T2's last event 12:32:31.773Z, the parent's 12:33:45.930Z, both `AgentMessage` / `phase: commentary`, no error, no rate limit, no context exhaustion; `~/ops/.codex-direct-mode` short-circuits `supervisor.sh:10` and crontab has no `supervisor.sh tick` while `launch_child.py:200` stamps `"supervised": true`. Verdict: 2 of 7 supervision points worth keeping, 5 are operational debt. The process-death *mechanism* is recorded as a hypothesis (root needed for `dmesg`); the *absence of any watcher* is proven. |
| REV-08 | **PASS** | `matt-pocock-code-review.md`, 380 lines, Standards and Spec axes kept separate with fixed-point receipts per finding. |
| REV-09 | **PASS** | `ponytail-audit.md`, 160 lines, raw ranked output preserved verbatim and then interpreted separately, so the correctness review and the complexity review cannot contaminate each other. Deletion estimate: −2,457 lines, −34 of 49 control files, −16 ops artifacts, −10.5 GB of idle worktrees, ~30 manual steps, and **0 of 12 evidence files**. |
| REV-10 | **PASS** | `outside-the-box-review.md`, 25 challenges (6 critical, 8 high), including the two that changed the recommendation: funnel measurability at 2.5 of 14 steps, and ~28 months to detect a +30% Meta creative difference at current volume. Recommendation: build directly rather than resume. |
| REV-11 | **PASS** | `consolidated-findings.md`, 30 findings with stable IDs. Every Critical and High row carries decisive evidence (file and line, or a reproduced browser interaction, or a command and its output) and a decisive retest. Orchestrator independently re-verified the five most consequential claims before admitting them: `curl -L` on both conversion URLs (404 and 200); `index.html:460`/`:519`; `git log --all --diff-filter=A` on the stage-3 report path (never committed on any branch); `deck.js:26-33` (only the agent name is interpolated); `tracking-audit.md` cache section at source. |
| REV-12 | **PASS** | `enhance-simplify-align-plan.md`, 404 lines. Every item carries one of the six mandated dispositions. **The plan was re-sequenced after lanes 1 and 2 landed**: the cache fix (P0-01) now precedes the CRM source column, because adding a source column while the cache is poisoned writes wrong click IDs rather than none — a known gap becoming a confident error. The corrected five-step order is stated explicitly. |
| REV-13 | **PASS** | `index.html` renders at 1280×900 DSF1; every internal link resolves to a file in this directory; heading structure is single-`h1`-per-section; no external network dependency. Verified by the link-resolution and render check recorded in `run-receipt.json`. |
| REV-14 | **PASS** | `git diff --name-only 8351b59..HEAD` — every changed path is under `outputs/reviews/fusion-ppc-system-audit-20260830/` plus `docs/runs/`. Child branches untouched. `main` untouched at `21d6873`; the mission contains no `SHIP: true`, so no merge and no deploy occurred. No live Ads, Meta, GA4, GTM, CRM, WordPress or production mutation. No message sent to any client or lead. No credentials read — `access-ledger.md` records 12 probes A-01..A-12, all read-only, none requiring a secret. USD 0 spent. |
| REV-15 | **PASS** | Five lanes, all returning `READY_FOR_PARENT_ACCEPTANCE` with structured receipts: lane 1 (51 requirements / 66 flows), lane 2 (10 targets, 38 pass / 33 fail), lane 3 (38 measurement / 7 trigger rows), lane 4 (Standards + Spec + Ponytail), lane 5 (25 challenges). **Independent reconciliation performed, and it changed the record twice**: lane 5 reported both conversion URLs as malformed — live `curl` showed one 404s and one returns 200, so one is dead and one is armed, which is the more dangerous of the two; and the orchestrator's own ground truth claimed T2 produced nothing, which lane 3 refuted and the orchestrator then verified and corrected. **Deviation recorded, not concealed:** `delegate-to-session-w-goal-loop`'s persistent transport is Codex-only (`gpt-5.6-sol`), which conflicts with the mandate's explicit "do not silently downgrade to Sonnet, Haiku, Codex, Sol". The lanes therefore ran as in-process Claude Opus executors preserving every other element of the skill's logic — frozen checksum-addressed goal, per-lane return contract, parent revalidation. Lane effort inherited the session default `xhigh`, at or above the mandated `high`, never below. Both are recorded in `run-state.md` as limitations, not presented as compliance. |