# Independent final visual QA

Current verdict: revision 2 inspected all 20 exact PNG captures and found no visual failures. Revision 1 below is retained as history and its related coverage gaps are superseded. Model routing and metadata limits are stated in the report.


### Status and goal

**DONE, revision 1:** independently inspected every public image in the supplied final deployment batch and recorded the evidence and its limits. The deployed screenshot set shows the requested desktop, intermediate, and mobile form layouts with no visible broken assets, overlap, or horizontal overflow. The page-wide visual verdict remains **PARTIAL** because the new step-1 card is cut off at 808px and 390px, and the Kíséret regression image cuts off its lower CTA. Those are evidence gaps, not proven page defects.

**Goal:** visually inspect the final deployed Balionline page at `https://balionline.hu/csoportos-utak-gyujtooldal/`, deployment marker WPCode 526 SHA `af1ab001daf14811aa9fd3187df0dd477375d08f728c9f518ebed9a8d87795ba`.

### Overview

I opened all 16 public JPEGs using `view_image` at original resolution. I excluded the two private CRM images in the manifest. The source manifest timestamps the public images from 2026-09-30 16:28:28 through 16:34:55 UTC. No browser, source, deployment, CAPTCHA, consent, account, or CRM actions were performed. Spend: $0; shared task cap: $20.

### Inputs

- Capture inventory: `continuation-20260930/ui/final/capture-manifest.json` (18 total entries: 16 public, 2 private).
- Layout/state evidence: `final-hero-geometry.json`, `final-step3-layout.json`, `final-capture-metadata.json`, `final-question-retention.json`, and `final-unaffected-sections.json` in the same folder.
- Raster sizes below are from the manifest; requested viewport, DPR, scroll, and layout bounds are from the companion JSON when present. Requested dimensions exceed raster dimensions by the browser-capture crop (for example, requested 390×844, raster 380×822). DPR is 1 in the geometry/capture records.

### Inspection

#### Blind description

The page has the Analit header above a dark, layered Bali lake hero. The left column has a large hand-drawn white and orange headline, two calls to action, and a short paragraph. A rounded white multi-step request card sits on the right at desktop widths and below the copy on narrow widths. The card has a deep red heading band, a three-step progress indicator, pale form controls, orange accents, and red submit buttons. In step 3, name and question span the form width; email and phone sit in two columns on wider screens and stack on mobile. A visible Cloudflare checkbox and consent row precede the actions. The two regression captures show the Benne van and Kíséret content cards on a white background.

#### Criterion comparison

| Page / viewport / state | Section, segment, run; requested viewport → raster; DPR / scroll / recorded bounds | Screenshot filename | What the image shows | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Collection page, 1440, step 1 | Hero top; 1440×1000 → 1430×993; DPR 1, scroll 0. Header y0–112; hero height 914.36; copy x119–683/y142–649.63; card x747–1311/y142–830.36. | `final-hero-step1-1440.jpg` | Header clears the hero. Dark lake image is layered behind the left-aligned copy. Full step-1 card fits; title, options, selects, and TOVÁBB are visible. Heading and body roles appear as Protest Riot and Open Sans; geometry says both fonts loaded. | PASS |
| Collection page, 1085, step 1 | Hero top; 1085×1174 → 1075×1163; DPR 1, scroll 0. Header bottom 80; hero height 914.36; copy x24–505.5/y142–591.08; card x569.5–1051/y142–830.36. | `final-hero-step1-1085.jpg` | Header switches to compact navigation. Copy remains left of the full form card, which fits within the image. Text, controls, and button are visible without overlap. | PASS |
| Collection page, 808, step 1 | Hero top; 808×1000 → 798×988; DPR 1, scroll 0. Header bottom 80; hero bottom 1324.27; copy x24–774/y128–512.44; card x89–709/y552.44–1240.27. | `final-hero-step1-808.jpg` | Copy is above the centered card and the red card heading, progress, and first choice row are visible. The viewport ends before the form card bottom at y1240.27, so the lower step-1 controls/action are absent from this batch. | UNVERIFIED |
| Collection page, 390, step 1 | Hero top; 390×844 → 380×822; DPR 1, scroll 0. Header bottom 80; hero bottom 1801.58; copy x24–356/y128–723.38; card x24–356/y763.38–1729.58. | `final-hero-step1-390.jpg` | Narrow copy and full-width choices stack cleanly. Only the red top of the card appears at the bottom. Nearly all step-1 card contents are outside the raster. | UNVERIFIED |
| Collection page, 1440, step 2 | Form top; 1440×1000 → 1430×993; DPR 1; visible top-of-page, scroll 0 by screenshot. No per-capture step-2 geometry row exists. | `final-form-step2-1440.jpg` | Step 2 is active; season choices, flexible-date checkbox, accommodation select, budget slider, and back/continue buttons are laid out in the card. No visible overlap or clipping in the shown card. | PASS |
| Collection page, 1440, step 3, lower | Lower viewport segment; 1440×1000 → 1430×993; DPR 1, scroll 146. State JSON body box x747–1311, viewport y138.38–840.58, document y284.38–986.58; CAPTCHA viewport y642.39–714.98. | `final-form-step3-1440.jpg` | Shows the lower portion of the card, including name, side-by-side email/phone, optional question, consent, CAPTCHA, and actions. The title/top of card is above this crop; pair with the upper capture. | PASS |
| Collection page, 1440, step 3, upper | Upper segment; 1440×1000 → 1430×993; DPR 1, scroll 0. Paired state body document y284.38–986.58, x747–1311. | `final-form-step3-upper-1440.jpg` | The complete red card heading and all fields fit from the top; it overlaps the lower segment. CAPTCHA is fully inside the card; buttons are visible. | PASS |
| Collection page, 1085, step 3 | Main segment; 1085×1174 → 1075×1163; DPR 1, scroll 59. State JSON body x569.5–1051, viewport y225.38–927.58, document y284.38–986.58; CAPTCHA y729.39–801.98. | `final-form-step3-1085.jpg` | Full card from heading through actions appears. Name/question span the card; email and phone are side-by-side. CAPTCHA and controls are contained. | PASS |
| Collection page, 1019, step 3, lower | Lower segment; 1019×1164 → 1009×1153; DPR 1, scroll 85. State JSON body x536.5–985, viewport y220.56–943.16, document y305.56–1028.16; CAPTCHA y744.97–817.56. | `final-form-step3-1019.jpg` | Lower card and buttons are visible; email and phone remain side-by-side. Consent wraps onto two lines but remains inside the card. Upper crop supplies the card heading. | PASS |
| Collection page, 1019, step 3, upper | Upper segment; 1019×1164 → 1009×1153; DPR 1, scroll 0. Paired state body document y305.56–1028.16, x536.5–985. | `final-form-step3-upper-1019.jpg` | Card heading and full field stack are visible. The question is full width and email/phone share a row. It overlaps the lower segment. | PASS |
| Collection page, 808, step 3, lower | Lower segment; 808×1000 → 798×988; DPR 1, scroll 648. State JSON body x89–709, viewport y46.81–749.02, document y694.81–1397.02; CAPTCHA y550.83–623.42. | `final-form-step3-808.jpg` | Lower card begins at the name field and continues through CAPTCHA and both actions. Email and phone remain side-by-side at this intermediate width. Upper segment shows the title and earlier card. | PASS |
| Collection page, 808, step 3, upper | Upper segment; 808×1000 → 798×988; DPR 1, scroll 350. Paired body document y694.81–1397.02, x89–709. | `final-form-step3-upper-808.jpg` | Red card heading, progress, and upper fields appear; lower screenshot overlaps the form and contains the actions. | PASS |
| Collection page, 390, step 3, lower | Lower segment; 390×844 → 380×822; DPR 1, scroll 964. State JSON body x24–356, viewport y−25.94–831.48, document y938.06–1795.48; CAPTCHA y584.30–653.02. | `final-form-step3-390.jpg` | Stacked email and phone, full-width optional question, wrapped consent, contained CAPTCHA, and full-width stacked VISSZA/KÜLDÉS are visible. The field top is cropped; pair with upper. | PASS |
| Collection page, 390, step 3, upper | Upper segment; 390×844 → 380×822; DPR 1, scroll 675. Paired body document y938.06–1795.48, x24–356. | `final-form-step3-upper-390.jpg` | Shows the red heading, progress, name, stacked email/phone, full-width question, and start of consent. It overlaps the lower segment, which shows CAPTCHA and actions. | PASS |
| Benne van regression, 1440 | Section capture; 1440×1000 → 1430×993; DPR 1, scroll 4606; recorded section y127.83–867.44. | `final-regression-benne-van-1440.jpg` | Four information cards and both section CTAs are visible in-frame; heading and card spacing are intact. | PASS |
| Kíséret regression, 1440 | Upper section capture; 1440×1000 → 1430×993; DPR 1, scroll 5345; recorded section y128.44–1142.72. | `final-regression-kiseret-1440.jpg` | Heading, callout, and four service cards are visible. The section continues below the raster; the CTA buttons are cut off at the bottom. Historical full-section coverage exists, but is not part of this final image. | UNVERIFIED |

#### Criterion findings

- **Header, hero, copy, background, type:** visible at all four step-1 widths. The heading is left-aligned; the dark layered lake remains legible behind it. The 808px and 390px layouts place the copy above the card, with no visible collision. Geometry records no overflow and loaded heading/body fonts.
- **Steps 1/2/3 and field rules:** all three steps are represented. Step 3 has no extra contact-title heading in the five layout records. Name and optional question use full rows. Email/phone remain paired at 1440, 1085, 1019, and 808, then stack at 390. The optional question is visibly present and has no required marker.
- **Controls and CAPTCHA:** recorded buttons are 52px high with 7px radius; red actions use `rgb(204, 0, 0)`. At 390, the VISSZA and KÜLDÉS buttons stack at full width. CAPTCHA is visually contained and unchecked in the step-3 segments. The consent box is also unchecked. Do not read these screenshots as successful CAPTCHA, consent, or submission.
- **Form-state evidence:** companion JSON records `contactTitleAbsent: true` and `overflow: false` for all five step-3 viewport layouts. `final-question-retention.json` records that the optional question value survived back/forward and that an empty optional question was valid. These are browser-state metrics, not proof of successful submit, email delivery, or CRM write.
- **Rendering defects:** no broken image, visible text collision, card overlap, or horizontal page overflow found in the inspected pixels. At 1019, consent wraps but stays inside the card. At narrower inputs, the long synthetic email value is clipped by the input's visible width, while the control itself remains within the form; no page-level overflow is shown.

### Deliverables preview

**Visual verdict:** PASS for the visible states listed above. UNVERIFIED for step-1 lower content at 808/390 and the Kíséret lower CTA in this final screenshot batch. No implementation defect was established by the images, so there is no source fix to recommend.

**Exact root follow-up for complete visual coverage:** capture only the missing deployed states: (1) step 1 at 808px after a moderate downward scroll so the lower controls and action appear, overlapping the existing top raster; (2) step 1 at 390px at an intermediate scroll and again lower down so the entire card is covered with overlap; and (3) the Kíséret section after roughly 200px more scroll than the existing 5345 position so its lower CTA appears, overlapping the existing image. Then attach those few images to the same review set and re-evaluate only those rows. Existing historical full-section coverage is context, not a substitute for these final-batch captures.

Screenshots prove visible state only. Successful submission, notification email, and CRM persistence remain unverified because no submission was made and no provider readback is part of this image review.

### Deliverable / evidence state

- **Created:** this revision-1 inspection report at the assigned path.
- **Inspected:** 16/16 public images at original resolution via `view_image`; 2 private CRM captures excluded.
- **Published / sent / deployed:** N/A. No external state changed.
- **Child:** `/root/final_visual_luna_a`, local native collaboration thread `01a0f334-261c-7581-aa52-b79e2adf5076`.
- **Executor model:** the assignment required `gpt-6-luna xhigh`; model and reasoning-effort metadata were not surfaced in this child context, so that requirement is unverified here.
- **Parent:** `/root`, local thread `01a0efdd-e3e0-79b2-9bb6-6b0b35b3f0f7`.
- **Acceptance:** child inspection/report criteria are complete; parent acceptance is pending. Root owns the optional missing-state captures and final combined verdict.

## Revision 2 — native PNG correction

Revision 2 supersedes revision 1's screenshot-coverage gaps. The 16 JPEG findings above remain as the historical first pass. This correction inspects the complete replacement set of 20 raw PNGs and their per-capture basis files.

### Status and goal

**DONE, revision 2:** all 20 public PNGs were individually opened with `view_image` at original resolution. The step-1 mobile/808 gaps, mobile step-2 state, and Kíséret lower CTA now have overlapping coverage. All 20 captures are PASS for their visible layout. No implementation defect was found. Submission, email delivery, and CRM persistence remain outside visual proof.

### Inputs

- `continuation-20260930/ui/native-final/capture-manifest.json`: 20 public images, 20/20 corresponding basis records.
- Capture method recorded for each: `Raw Chromium Page.captureScreenshot, PNG, no postprocessing`.
- Each PNG raster exactly matches its requested viewport at DPR 1. The 10px scrollbar is included in the raster; `clientWidth` is 10px narrower. Every basis record names build `af1ab001daf14811aa9fd3187df0dd477375d08f728c9f518ebed9a8d87795ba` and URL `https://balionline.hu/csoportos-utak-gyujtooldal/`.
- Root reports no source changes after that build; the capture markers agree. I did not inspect source or provider state.
- All captures are from 2026-09-30 16:59–17:01 UTC. Per-image viewport, scroll, and form/section document bounds are recorded in the table. All 20 basis records report `overflow: false`.

### Inspection

#### Blind description

The unscaled screenshots show the Analit header, dark lake hero, large white/orange hand-drawn headline, and rounded red/white multi-step form card. At wide viewports, copy and card sit side by side; at 808px and 390px the card follows the copy. Step 1 has three activity choices plus travel-party, traveller-count, and nights selects. Step 2 has season choices, date, accommodation, budget slider, and actions. Step 3 has name, email, phone, optional question, consent, CAPTCHA, and actions. Mobile captures show these tall cards in overlapping scroll positions. The Kíséret content appears as four service cards followed by two calls to action in the lower segment.

#### Criterion comparison

| Page / viewport / state | Segment; raster=requested viewport; DPR / scroll / recorded bounds | PNG filename | Visual observation | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Collection, 1440, step 1 | Hero top; 1440×1000; DPR 1, scroll 0. Hero doc y0–914.36; form x747–1311/y142–830.36. | `native-hero-step1-1440.png` | Header clears the dark lake hero. Left-aligned headline and copy; full step-1 card and TOVÁBB fit with generous lower hero space. | PASS |
| Collection, 1085, step 1 | Hero top; 1085×1174; DPR 1, scroll 0. Hero doc y0–914.36; form x569.5–1051/y142–830.36. | `native-hero-step1-1085.png` | Compact header; complete two-column hero and full card fit. Controls and action visible. | PASS |
| Collection, 808, step 1 | Top; 808×1000; DPR 1, scroll 0. Form x89–709/doc y552.44–1240.27. | `native-hero-step1-808-top.png` | Copy precedes centered card. Upper capture shows the title, activity choices, and start of selects. | PASS |
| Collection, 808, step 1 | Lower; 808×1000; DPR 1, scroll 430. Same form bounds; viewport y122.44–810.27. | `native-hero-step1-808-lower.png` | Overlaps the top capture and shows both selects and TOVÁBB; full card and lower spacing fit. | PASS |
| Collection, 390, step 1 | Top; 390×844; DPR 1, scroll 0. Form x24–356/doc y763.38–1729.58. | `native-hero-step1-390-top.png` | Tall headline and copy stack cleanly above the card, whose heading starts at the raster bottom. | PASS |
| Collection, 390, step 1 | Middle; 390×844; DPR 1, scroll 650. Same form bounds; viewport y113.38–1079.58. | `native-hero-step1-390-middle.png` | Overlaps top; shows heading, progress, all three stacked activity cards, and upper selects. | PASS |
| Collection, 390, step 1 | Lower; 390×844; DPR 1, scroll 1050. Same form bounds; viewport y−286.63–679.58. | `native-hero-step1-390-lower.png` | Overlaps middle; shows selects, traveller count, nights, and full-width TOVÁBB. Card bottom is visible. | PASS |
| Collection, 1440, step 2 | Main; 1440×1000; DPR 1, scroll 0. Form x747–1311/doc y142–949.20. | `native-form-step2-1440.png` | Full desktop form, selected season, date, accommodation, budget slider, and both actions fit without clipping. | PASS |
| Collection, 390, step 2 | Upper; 390×844; DPR 1, scroll 650. Form x24–356/doc y763.38–1711.80; viewport y113.38–1061.80. | `native-form-step2-390-upper.png` | Shows step-2 title, season grid in two columns, date, flexible-date control, accommodation, and budget value. | PASS |
| Collection, 390, step 2 | Lower; 390×844; DPR 1, scroll 1100. Same form bounds; viewport y−336.63–611.80. | `native-form-step2-390-lower.png` | Overlaps upper and shows slider, fare note, stacked VISSZA/TOVÁBB, and card bottom. | PASS |
| Collection, 1440, step 3 | Main; 1440×1000; DPR 1, scroll 0. Form x747–1311/doc y142–986.58. | `native-form-step3-1440.png` | Full card, including title, progress, fields, consent, unchecked contained CAPTCHA, and actions, fits the viewport. | PASS |
| Collection, 1085, step 3 | Main; 1085×1174; DPR 1, scroll 0. Form x569.5–1051/doc y142–986.58. | `native-form-step3-1085.png` | Full form fits. Name and optional question are full rows; email and phone share a row; CAPTCHA and actions are contained. | PASS |
| Collection, 1019, step 3 | Main; 1019×1164; DPR 1, scroll 0. Form x536.5–985/doc y128–1028.16. | `native-form-step3-1019.png` | Full card and actions are visible. Email and phone remain side by side; consent wraps inside the card. | PASS |
| Collection, 808, step 3 | Upper; 808×1000; DPR 1, scroll 430. Form x89–709/doc y552.44–1397.02; viewport y122.44–967.02. | `native-form-step3-808-upper.png` | Shows card title, progress, all fields, consent, CAPTCHA, and actions. | PASS |
| Collection, 808, step 3 | Lower; 808×1000; DPR 1, scroll 650. Same form bounds; viewport y−97.56–747.02. | `native-form-step3-808-lower.png` | Overlaps upper and confirms lower form/card boundary, CAPTCHA containment, and both actions. | PASS |
| Collection, 390, step 3 | Upper; 390×844; DPR 1, scroll 650. Form x24–356/doc y763.38–1795.48; viewport y113.38–1145.48. | `native-form-step3-390-upper.png` | Shows heading, progress, name, stacked email/phone, and full-width optional question. | PASS |
| Collection, 390, step 3 | Lower; 390×844; DPR 1, scroll 1050. Same form bounds; viewport y−286.63–745.48. | `native-form-step3-390-lower.png` | Overlaps upper and shows consent, contained unchecked CAPTCHA, stacked full-width actions, and card bottom. | PASS |
| Benne van regression, 1440 | Section; 1440×1000; DPR 1, scroll 4606. Section document y4733.83–5473.44; viewport y127.83–867.44. | `native-regression-benne-van-1440.png` | Four cards and both CTAs are fully visible in-frame. | PASS |
| Kíséret regression, 1440 | Upper; 1440×1000; DPR 1, scroll 5345. Section document y5473.44–6487.72; viewport y128.44–1142.72. | `native-regression-kiseret-1440-upper.png` | Shows heading, callout, service cards, and top of the CTA row; lower action area is outside this frame and is covered by the paired lower image. | PASS |
| Kíséret regression, 1440 | Lower; 1440×1000; DPR 1, scroll 5604. Same section bounds; viewport y−130.56–883.72. | `native-regression-kiseret-1440-lower.png` | Overlaps upper and shows all four cards plus both complete CTAs and section bottom. Together the pair covers the entire recorded section. | PASS |

#### Criterion findings

- The 808px hero pair overlaps by about 570px and covers the full step-1 card. The 390px hero top/middle/lower sequence overlaps by about 194px and 444px, respectively, and covers the full card. The 390px step-2 and step-3 pairs overlap by about 394px and 444px. The 808px step-3 pair overlaps by about 780px.
- The Kíséret pair overlaps by about 741px and jointly covers its full recorded section bounds, including both CTAs. Benne van is fully contained in one frame.
- Desktop/intermediate layout preserves side-by-side email/phone; 390px stacks them. Name and optional question remain full width. CAPTCHA and consent are visible and unchecked. No title, broken image, visible overlap, clipped card/action, or horizontal page overflow was found in the inspected pixels.
- Layout basis records say `overflow: false`; this is supporting state metadata, not a substitute for the raster review. No screenshot proves submit, email, or CRM outcomes.

### Deliverables preview

**Revision-2 visual verdict: PASS for all 20 captures.** The previous screenshot gaps are closed; there is no remaining visual capture request from this child. No code, source, provider, or CRM state changed.

**Runtime model receipt:** the saved `turn_context` records for this child thread (records at lines 8 and 222) report `model: gpt-6-luna` and `effort: xhigh`. This independently confirms the requested runtime. The parent's supported launch parameters express the request; the child's own turn-context is the actual-runtime evidence. No raw transcript or private tool output was inspected or included.

**Exact root next step:** integrate this revision-2 visual PASS with the other required QA receipts, keeping submission/email/CRM proof separate. No further screenshot capture or source fix is indicated by these 20 images.

### Deliverable / evidence state

- **Created:** revision-2 evidence appended to the assigned report; revision-1 findings are retained above as history.
- **Inspected:** 20/20 native PNGs via `view_image`; 20/20 per-capture basis files read; all manifest raster sizes equal requested viewport dimensions.
- **Published / sent / deployed:** N/A. No external state changed.
- **Child:** `/root/final_visual_luna_a`, local native thread `01a0f334-261c-7581-aa52-b79e2adf5076`.
- **Parent:** `/root`, local thread `01a0efdd-e3e0-79b2-9bb6-6b0b35b3f0f7`.
- **Acceptance:** revision-2 child criteria are complete; parent acceptance is pending.